PlantAmnesty Back to
Book Index

The Complete Guide to Landscape Design, Renovation, and Maintenance
by Cass Turnbull

TIMING
New gardeners are often overwhelmed by the deluge of conflicting advice they get as to the right time to prune. Some experts say to prune "when the shears are sharp," while others, warning about the way trees bleed in the spring, urge "dormant pruning."

I'd like to introduce the general rules of good timing and mention some specifics, too. A little known or appreciated fact is that pruning stimulates growth.

Spring
In the early springtime your plants are most vigorous and pruning will stimulate new growth the fastest; it's also the best time for a plant to recover from severe pruning. Try to wait until danger of frost is gone, because if your pruning stimulates lots of new soft growth, this growth might freeze off. It will not freeze the old "hardened off" wood, though. Spring is a good time to renovate your giant aucuba ball, when you will be cutting into all that black looking inside growth, and this will give it maximum time to green up again. When you radically reduce the size of a hedge, you expose ugly dead looking branches. If you must do this, know that early spring is when the new growth will come back fastest. Spring is a good time to prune anything that you are worried about killing with heavy pruning. Rhododendrons are touchy, and sometimes when you prune back to an old node (branch or bud), the whole branch simply dies. Early spring is when they are most vigorous and you can spot swelling hidden buds along the stems, to cut back to. You will have a better change of stimulating growth.

Spring is the time for bud work. You can rub off new buds growing from places where you've thinned off branches before--this may stop them from becoming suckers (or watersprouts). In my area, where the climate is mild, early spring (Washington's Birthday) is when we heavily prune back hybrid tea type roses. It is easy to spot the swelling buds to cut back to. Later in the spring is the time to prune the elongating buds called candles from the tips of pines. The Japanese either twist or cut them off, or even cut them in half. This prevents pines from getting bigger and gives them the puff of clouds look. It's how you stop your pine from becoming enormous. It's almost impossible to make pines smaller again without ruining their natural form. It is far better to thin or layer your pines as they grow than to wait until you think they are suddenly too big and then try to make them smaller.

Contrary to common practice, spring is not a good time to prune fruit trees or flowering ornamentals (flowering and fruiting cherries, plums, crabapples). This is because these plants are prone to suckering back. Suckers, you recall, are the weak, wild, skinny, upright branches that often result from wounding or pruning. The more heavily you prune, the more suckers you get. So always go lightly in pruning these trees, say one-eighth of total green area in any one year. Avoid heading cuts on the ornamentals (means not fruit trees).

Other readily suckering plants are magnolias, dogwood, witch hazel, figs, parrotia and hazel nut (filbert). You should prune these generally in the summer to reduce sucker regrowth. There is another group of trees (maple, dogwood, pine, birch) called "bleeders," that lose sap at a frightening rate if you prune in the spring. I am told that this loss of sap does not actually endanger the plant's health, but it looks messy. Prune these trees in the summer or winter. Grapes bleed as well.

Avoid pruning all trees during the weeks in spring that they are forming leaves, and during the time the leaves are falling in the autumn. These are times of low energy for your trees and the added stress of pruning is not wise.

Summer

Summer pruning is less stimulating to plant growth. It is, however, somewhat more stressful to the plant, so be sure your plants are well watered and healthy and don't pick on rhododendrons or other touchy shrubs. Summertime is great for spotting dead wood, as you know. Because of the nonstimulating effect of summer pruning, it is a good time to tidy up that laurel hedge or those abelias, because they won't grow back right away. Summer pruning in the Pacific Northwest means June and July. In hotter climates, ease off even earlier. Summer is a good time to snap out new sucker growth, or cut it off. Battling suckers is much of what I do as a pruner. Avoid heavy pruning (except for suckers) during droughts. Drought is stressful on plants; so is heavy pruning. Also, it will take a long time for your plant to regrow. You may burn some previously shaded leaves or the bark inside your plant or tree.

Fall
Fall pruning is risky only with certain plants. Some plants are considered tender, which means their tips freeze back easily, and sometimes whole branches do. (In my climate zone, roses, choisya, laurestinus, Viburnum tinus, raphiolepis, and laurels are tender.) I have noticed that many of these are the plants that take full sun. It makes sense that these plants, perhaps from warmer climes, are not used to colder weather. Also, in the fall, when the days are somewhat warm and wet, plants are occasionally tricked into thinking spring is back, so you may not wish to chance stimulating more soft tender growth. Some people feel that fall pruning is rather stressful on plants, but a little thinning and touching up is always in order in any season. You can, of course, always take out the dead wood.

Winter
Winter is a favorite time for professional gardeners to prune, especially trees. That's because we are usually too busy weeding and doing absolutely essential pruning in the spring and summer. In winter we have the time to get out our ladders and dive in among the branches and really sort the garden out. Winter pruning also stimulates growth (next spring), but less so than spring pruning. When all the leaves are gone, it's easier to see the branch pattern on some of the big deciduous shrubs, such as forsythias and European cranberries (Viburnum opulus).

Bloom Time

Another consideration for deciding when to prune is flower production. You will read that some plants bloom on year-old wood, or two-year-old wood, or on buds set up this season, or that are maximum on three-year-old wood. This is all very confusing. A good rule of thumb is to prune right after blooming so that the plant has time to set up buds for the next year. But it's just a consideration for gardeners who are really into their flowers. You know it does not hurt the shrub to prune it at the wrong time. You don't shock buds into not forming, you just cut off some. In fact, some gardeners prune before blooming so that they can bring in the barren-looking twigs of, say, forsythia, quince, sweet smelling witch hazel, put them into vases of water, and force them to bloom early in their warm homes. Such are the rewards for clever gardeners. If you are selectively pruning and thinning your shrub or tree, this should not make a big difference to the casual observer come bloom time. It makes a big difference only if you shear or otherwise head back all the branches of your shrub after it has made its flower buds; then you will be cutting off all the buds. But you shouldn't be shearing your flowering shrubs, anyway. I pay closer attention to bloom time when pruning plants that have one big show and then quit, as opposed to ones that push out flowers on and off throughout the season.

Now you have the facts before you, and you may decide for yourself when to prune. There are many oddities to know about plants that you can look up in your local pruning encyclopedia. You will, however, have to know the names of your shrubs first. I suggest you make a little map and get the lady with the yard down the block to come help you identify them; she will be flattered. Or you may want to hire a professional gardener; he or she can get you off to a good start, too. In any case, don't be intimidated by the notion of right time pruning. If you are out renovating your yard, it's then that you "prune when the shears are sharp."

SUMMARY
People make too big a deal out of proper timing. General thinning is okay almost any time of year.
Following are general results of pruning at different seasons of the year.
1. Spring - Produces rapid regrowth. A good time for any bud work. Watch out for "bleeders" (maple, dogwood, walnut, grape, birch).
2. Summer - Summer has a somewhat dwarfing effect, but is harder on health of plant; a good time to battle suckers; a good to spot dead wood on deciduous plants.
3. Fall - May be stressful on plants. May stimulate tender growth that will freeze when winter comes. General light thinning is always in order.
4. Winter - Good to prune deciduous plants. Traditional time for fruit trees. Good for heavy work. Will also stimulate growth next spring.

Forward to Pruning Cane-Growers

Back to Looking for Dead Wood