PlantAmnesty Back to
Book Index

The Complete Guide to Landscape Design, Renovation, and Maintenance
by Cass Turnbull

FERTILIZERS AND ORGANICS
The biggest difference in the health and looks of your shrubs and trees is, once again, going to depend mostly on whether or not you have poor soil, poor drainage, or too little irrigation or plants which are ill-suited for their sites (i.e., shade lovers in the sun). Fertilizers cannot make up for deficiencies in these areas any more than pruning can. Fertilizers can, however, make a significant contribution to the overall robustness and health of your garden subjects, once their basic needs are met.

N-P-K
Plants do not eat fertilizer; they manufacture their food from sunshine. They also "breathe" air not only with their leaves, but the trunks of trees and their roots need access to air. The base of a tree is apt to smother if covered over with soil during construction. Plants use the CO2 in the air and give off O2 as a waste product (lucky for us). Plants take up water and elements and simple compounds from the soil to complete biological activity. Plants use, in order of most needed, Nitrogen, Phosphorous (P2O2) and Potassium or Potash (K2O), or N-P-K as they are usually called. The three numbers on your fertilizer bag always stand for the percentage by weight of these three elements in that same order in the bag. If you have all three numbers, then you have what's called a "complete fertilizer." Plants also use minute amounts of what are known as micro nutrients. A deficiency in one of these may affect your plant, though this is rather uncommon. Mostly, it is said, plants want nitrogen.

Fertilizers vary in their relative amounts of N-P-K and in the specific form of each element. But it's all the same stuff, basically. You don't "feed" your roses something different than you put on your lawn--it's just in relatively different amounts, the N-nitrogen of N-P-K is primarily known as good to produce leafy green growth. The P and K are used to assist in making bigger flowers, better roots, for winter hardiness, and disease resistance. Your grass fertilizer will be heavy on nitrogen, your fertilizer for flowers or vegetables will have more P and K. Bigger numbers on the bag simply mean it's in a more concentrated form. People who understand math will use these numbers in a formula to compare prices of different bags of fertilizer to find out which one gives you the more bang per buck. Also, they calculate application rates for their fertilizer. The general rule is two to six pounds of actual nitrogen per 1000 square feet per year for lawns, less for shrub beds. Adjust your fertilizer spreader to distribute fertilizer at the correct rate. Go to an empty lot, pace off 100 feet by 10 feet (= 1,000 square feet), put two pounds of real nitrogen (a percentage of the bag according to label) and adjust it until it comes out right. The same method can be used to adjust the rate of application for liquids, except you can use water during the trials and also calibrate on an easy-to-measure concrete surface, like the driveway. When measuring it is useful to remember, "A pint is a pound, the world around," thus converting weight into volume.

Formulations
Fertilizers come in different formulations--some are simple enough to be taken up by the plant immediately but won't hang around long in the soil--a shot in the arm--needing to be reapplied more often. Fertilizers with more complex compounds break down more slowly, releasing their goodies to the plants over time and are less likely to burn roots. Some, like Osmocote ___, are coated with something that allows the fertilizer to be released when the weather is hotter and the plant needs it more. It is often used by nurseries for potted plants and for annual flower displays (marigolds, impatiens, etc.).

Fertilizers can be as complicated a subject as you care to investigate. You can load up on the various types and investigate for the best time for each plant. And, no doubt your plants will additionally benefit from the tailored care and attention. Or you can do like I do. I use a general, all-purpose shrub fertilizer in the late spring, and a grass fertilizer for my lawn in the late fall. Fertilize, if you can, when it's going to rain soon or water it in. Chemical fertilizers can burn leaves or roots if put on too heavily. People often burn up their lawns by applying too much fertilizer and then not watering it in. Fertilize in moderation. Running your plants at full steam ahead can damage them just as much as letting them starve for a little phosphorus. Use too much nitrogen and you have too many green soft shoots at the expense of flowers, fertilize too late and your plants may not harden off for the winter and get caught in an early frost. People, as always, get into trouble by using too much of a good thing. Give them what they need to be healthy, but don't push them.

Avoiding Over-Fertilizing
To avoid over fertilization I usually play it safe and get the lower-numbered sacks (numbers under twelve). To spread your fertilizer you can put it in a bucket and broadcast it. This means that, with your rubber-gloved hand, you just randomly throw it around, up in the air in a sweep as you walk. Avoid clusters of fertilizer pellets on the ground, which will cause burning or yellowing of grass blades. Then go back and "bang the bushes" to knock off excessive pellets. Others may choose to carefully sprinkle a light circle of fertilizer at the dripline at the base of the shrubs. You can also, for large areas and for more even coverage buy a plastic broadcast spreader. By turning the crank it just flies out at a relatively even rate.

Using Spreaders
Drop spreaders are those carts used by lawn worshipers to fertilize their lawns. Use this tool when applying a weed and feed which contains a broadleaf weed killer. If you put that in a cyclone-broadcast spreader it would go flying off into your shrub beds, killing broadleaf shrubs as well. Drop spreaders are trickier to get even-looking green grass. You have to divide your fertilizer into two parts and walk very straight lines--back and forth one way and then go the other way. If you inadvertently over fertilize or miss a section, the lawn will tell on you later, showing either streaks of lighter green or scorched yellow grass.

Be sure to wash yourself and your spreader after fertilizing; chemical fertilizers can be quite corrosive. Be careful with compounds containing iron (used for quick greening) as they can stain your concrete paths.

Chemical Vs. Organic Fertilizers
Plants are not damaged by giving them "chemical" fertilizers, but the long-term fertility of the soil may be degraded if it receives no other help than this. There are serious concerns that the over-application of nitrogen in chemical fertilizers is leaching down and contaminating ground water. This concern has been directed mainly to the agricultural use of fertilizers, but can reasonably be considered to apply to urban use as well. The longer I am in the business, the more I tend to throw my hand in with those of the organic philosophy.

All plants take up N-P-K in the same form; however, organic fertilizers have to be processed down into simpler compounds for the plants to take them up. Worms and entire communities of fungus, bacteria and protozoa do this work. This is good. They are attuned to the rhythms of nature. These micro organisms can't multiply and do their work until the ground warms up sufficiently in the spring. This keeps plants from growing before the time is right. With chemical fertilizers, on the other hand, all nutrients are readily available and can be used immediately, perhaps before they should be or when the plant should be slowing down in the fall.

Organic fertilizers are generally safer to use because their concentrations are much lower. The only common trouble I've heard of is that utilizing uncomposted manure-- specially chicken manure--can burn plants. This is why garden books always refer to manure as "well-rotted manure." Straight from the stables, manure can also contain unwanted weed seeds, and we know about them! Properly composting manure will eradicate most seeds, and the powdered stuff you buy in bags at the hardware or grocery store (or nursery) will be steamed or heat-treated to destroy seeds. It's great stuff!

Dried powdered manure can be spread just like chemical fertilizers. Some people go back and hoe it in or use a cultivator to sort of scratch it in. The fresh stuff, and especially if it gets wet, will--well--stink for a few weeks. If you can, apply it when it's cooler and raining a lot for this reason. After a week you'll no longer notice the smell. I don't mind the smell. To me it is "the smell of victory!" (to quote a line from the movie, Apocalypse Now).

Many insist that manure and compost are not fertilizers at all, since the actual nitrogen, phosphorus and potash available to or readily usable by the plants is small. They are, however, very good at feeding and sheltering the bacterial organisms and earthworms that do indeed create fertilizer.

Not all so-called organic fertilizers are organic (meaning once alive). Some are mined, like lime or phosphorus. Others, like blood and bone and fish meals were once certainly alive. The discovery that crop production could be increased with the addition of crushed bones to the soil allowed a hungry Europe of late 18th Century with a new, expanding city population, to continue to be supported by limited farmlands. England was accused of widespread pillaging of soldiers' cemeteries of Europe, to supply their farmers. The reliance on bone meal ended when it was discovered that the same nutrient-building compounds could be mined in rock form.

Nitrogen fertilizer in its first, most basic form--urine--is still used by organic gardeners. Some even use their own--diluted. Wood ashes are another classic source of useful compounds. Also, cottonseed meal, kelp and sludge (another human "fertilizer.")

What is it about these organic compounds that causes gardeners to talk about them with the same sort of glee that a chocoholic uses in describing a new dessert bar in town? Organic gardeners have experienced the joys of building up the perfect, healthy, living, thriving, fertile ecosystem we call soil.

Good soil is not just dirt. And the fertility of soil is more than the amounts of N P and K it contains. These elements must be available to the plants, and that depends on a host of other factors like the pH (acidity or alkalinity) of the soil, the cation (pronounced cat-eye-on) exchange capacity, the water holding capacity of soil, the size of soil particles, its texture, and air spaces. It does only temporary good for a sandy soil landscape to add chemical nitrogen, as the sand cannot hold it. The nitrogen will sluice through--perhaps polluting the water table. Whereas adding organic material will allow the soil to "hold" nitrogen and release it slowly to the plant. Organics not only add "nutrients" to the soil; they give it good soil structure. Furthermore, humus will act as a stabilizer for organic life.

More Gardenese
We are now moving from organics as fertilizers to organics as amendments. We will need to interpret some of these new gardenese verb-nouns for you backyard neophytes.

• Organic - means it was once alive
• Amend - a verb - means to add something to your soil, usually by digging it in.
• Amendment - a noun - the stuff you are digging in to your soil. Your soil amendment could be organic--like leaves--or inorganic--like sand.
• Mulch - verb - you remember, to spread a layer of something over your soil.
• Mulch - noun - the stuff you put on top of your soil. Mulches can be organic--like sawdust--or inorganic--like black plastic, ick!).
• Organic matter - the fresh stuff, like leaves, grass clippings, shredded bark, peat moss.
• Humus - organic matter that has sat around awhile and has been partially decomposed by bacteria. Leaf mold fits nicely into this category. That's just that old pile of leaves that's falling apart, but you can still tell it's leaves.
• Compost - noun - organic material that has been wholly decomposed by microbiological activity. Compost is usually made of green stuff (grass clippings) and brown stuff (autumn leaves, twigs), that's been kept in a heap for anywhere from three weeks to one year, whereupon it turns miraculously into dark, clean, earthy-smelling crumbly particles that look like dirt. People who compost love the fact that they have taken a troublesome waste product and turned it into "black gold" that you can't even buy at the so-called soil-sellers' yards.
• Compost - verb - the process of turning organic material into compost.

Now let's see if you can use these terms in sentences. One can mulch with compost or amend with compost. Or one could mulch with mulch, compost, or inorganic material, say red cinder rock. But one could never compost inorganic material, rocks just take too long to decompose. It is said that musicians don't die, they just decompose. Sorry, it's an old joke.

Compost
Building good soils by mulching with compost or humus becomes an obsession with most good gardeners. Unlike chemical fertilizers, compost feeds the whole ecosystem and keeps it healthy, not just the plants. I have done a little reading on compost, and its virtues are too numerous to explain here, but its most engaging quality seems to be its ability to solve totally opposite problems or imbalances in the garden. Soil too sandy? Add compost. Too much clay? Add compost. Soil have too many heavy metals or not fertile enough? Add compost. Compost seems to have a stabilizing effect in nature and its benefits are long range. Besides the plants love it, it looks good, it smells good, and it feels good in your hands.

A fairly easy compost program entails making a four- cubic-foot pile of leaves layered with grass clippings. Ideally, you use two parts grass to one part leaves. If you have a lot of room and a lot of organic material to get rid of, you can graduate to a hot compose system. There are several good books that explain hot composting. The heat generated by decomposition of the organic material is great enough to kill most weed seeds and disease organisms. So you can add more and different things to these piles, like weeds.

Composting, like most gardening, and even most of life, I guess, can be as simple or complex as you like. The mother of a friend of mine is a devoted gardener. He visited her one day and she proudly showed him her new three-bin compost system. Then she nipped inside to get a packet of something she sent away for in the mail--Compost Starter. Adding water to it, she then poured it reverently into one of the bins. "My god, Mother! exclaimed her son, "that's not a hobby, that's a religion!"

If making your own compost seems like too much trouble, you can buy it in bags or have a pile delivered to your house in many cities now. Commercial material is probably hot composted and the possibility of spreading weed seeds and plant disease is not a concern.

Wormss
Even more fascinating, I find, are worm boxes on display at my local Tilth Association demonstration garden, and at local nurseries and garden fairs. These are boxes wherein you place special starter "worms" and shredded newspaper--to these you add your table scraps. Miraculously, the worms multiply and the scraps turn into worm castings to be applied to your garden. Castings need not be broken down further for plants to use. Castings are fertilizer. They are, if you will, the straight poop. The reason robins can pick worms off so easily is because worms, being clean-living organisms, return to the surface to leave their castings. Don't underestimate the worms in your yard. Worms constantly mix and stir the soil, aerating it perfectly for roots to push through easily. They create vast and incredible amounts of fertilizer for your garden.

When you have good soil, you have worms and often when you have worms, you have moles that love to eat them. I was at a nursery recently when a customer asked how to get rid of moles. The nursery person recommended a product that when applied to the ground would gas all the worms to death, thus removing the moles' food source--presumably causing the moles to leave. Kill all the worms? Horrors!

Although occasional moderate use of chemical fertilizer is by all means acceptable, I encourage people to avoid over-reliance.

To sum up my own feelings about fertilizers and organics, I quote from the Washington State University Cooperative Extension Service bulletin #0648, Organic Gardening: "Your Long Range Objective should be to build your garden area to a high fertility level and then to maintain fertility through composting and mulches, reducing reliance on commercial and organic fertilizers."

SUMMARY
Fertilizer bags all have three numbers on them that stand for the amount (percentage by weight) of Nitrogen (N), Phosphorus (P) and Potassium (K). Nitrogen is, generally speaking, good for producing green growth. The P and K are for better roots, blooms, disease resistance and hardiness.
Don't overuse chemical fertilizers. You burn roots or leaves with over application or if you fail to water. Lower-numbered (numbers under twelve) sacks are less concentrated and therefore safer. Don't fertilize too early or too late, too often or too much.
Use organics; mulch, weed-seed-free compost, or dried manure to improve the long term fertility of the soil.
People always try to use pruning and fertilizing to make up for bad planning. Remedial pruning and fertilizing can only help to a certain point.
I think of chemical fertilizers in the same way as vitamin pills. They are no substitute for a healthy diet. Your soil will benefit greatly from a regular feeding of organic mulch.

Forward to Watering

Back to Herbicides