PlantAmnesty Back to
Book Index

The Complete Guide to Landscape Design, Renovation, and Maintenance
by Cass Turnbull

BEGIN TO BRING ORDER OUT OF CHAOS
So you've read the first section on pruning and you know it's not going to be enough. You have bought a yard where everything is enormous; you sense that some plant-happy person planted it thirty years ago and stopped taking care of it ten years ago. Or perhaps you never knew what to do yourself, so rather than ruin everything by pruning ignorantly, you let it all get way out of hand. Something has to be done.

Maybe you bought a yard full of giant sheared poodleballs, and globe aucubas, camellias, or something seems wrong with the fruit trees, maples, and dogwoods (they were topped or stripped and now are suckering back like crazy!); or you made some mistakes yourself. You know better now and you're ready to do right by your yard.

This is your section of the book. First read "How to Prune" so you don't get into trouble again, then come back to this.

Before you are allowed to begin major renovating you must read three case studies, to get your attitude adjusted. Then you can begin your chainsaw work.

Case Study #1: Lady Who Knows How to Treat a Tree
I got a call from a lady a few years ago who wanted help in her yard. I knew I wanted to work for her just from the way she talked about her Empress tree. She called it her "grand lady." She proudly referred to the month in spring when its giant purple (foxglove-like) blooms made such a spectacular show that she could hear the squeal of brakes as passing motorists stopped to take a longer look.

This lady, Ms. K., has caught the gardening bug, and she has a bad case. She gladly pays the price of owning a huge (sixty-five foot) and uncommon tree. It's a big price. For one, the rest of her yard and house are rather small and shrub bed space is at a premium. It's difficult to grow things under a tree that takes up half her front yard. She must add lots of fertilizer and seek out tough plants that can survive the shade and root competition. She must water extra diligently in the summer since the thick canopy of leaves prevents rain from reaching the plants below. She's done a great job.

The Empress tree is a messy tree. Branches die back and fall off and have to be cleared out to keep the beds looking good. The "grand lady" is always dropping something that has to be cleaned up. Its giant round leaves fall by the tons in the fall. In the spring Ms. K. rakes dead blossoms, then husks of seed pods during the summer.

Our proud gardener knows that she is caretaker of a treasure and it's worth the trouble--she's got the biggest and best tree in the neighborhood.

She tells the story of the previous owners, who were finally so fed up with all the leaf raking that they hired someone to come cut the tree down. The chainsaw was actually started when two alert neighbors ran up the street to literally exclaim, "Woodsman, spare that tree!" And they promised to rake all the leaves for free, to ensure the tree's survival. All things worth having and doing take time and care. There are no maintenance-free yards. An appreciation of beauty can make your yard chores less burdensome.

Case Study #2: Big Mess--Small Mess
I went on a consulting job last year to a young woman's home. She was beginning her second year there and didn't know where to begin. The garden had been planted by a plant lover (phytophile) but had been let go for several years. Grass was coming up through most of the plants in the back. Some previous homeowner had sheared the camellias and escallonias. Many things were overgrown, running into each other, over sidewalks and steps. Some plants were looking leggy and sick because they were finally being shaded out by trees that had gotten big. Unfortunately she had hired Maul-and-Haul landscapers before she reached me, and they had managed to mal-prune several of the trees and shrubs.

It is unfortunate that one of the first responses to an overgrown yard is to go out and cut everything back, thus creating a smaller mess rather than a big mess. It also makes the final solution more difficult. It will often take years to sort out some types of badly pruned plants.

In this case the perpetrator had topped a young spruce. Not one hundred feet away on a neighbor's property sat a previously topped conifer that now boasted an ugly double leader.

Also, sad to say in this yard, the same fellow had topped her little dogwood. In this crowded area a skimmia was reaching up into the dogwood tree, and her dogwood was a little out of sorts as well. What should have been done was to re-define the areas between plants, pruning to lower the skimmia (selectively pruning, of course) and to visually raise the dogwood by removing some of the limbs hanging too far down into the skimmia. The dogwood needed to be selectively pruned and thinned to make it look cleaner, clearer, and much more beautiful, in such a fashion that the casual observer could not see where it had been pruned.

Because of the topping her dogwood suckered back in the next year--the Hydra effect--and looked really awful. It will take years of patient restorative work to get it back in shape. If it had been done properly just once, the amount of upkeep would have been minimal in successive years. Oh well, this is one of those stories repeated endlessly everywhere. Don't you make the "cut-it-all-back" mistake.

Throwing Out The Baby with The Bath Water
I get so nervous when I drive by beautiful old landscapes that have been ignored for ten to twenty years. I know they're in for it, especially big ones. There's a parking lot in the neighborhood I grew up in that I'm very worried about. It has lots of wonderful old plants, including one thing I can't identify (thus making it doubly rare and wonderful) with big pink fuzzy blooms in the late summer. (No, I don't think it's a tamarix.)

Frequently, when homeowners' or business owners' landscapes get out of control, they just remove them totally. EGAD! You drive by one day and thirty years of mother nature's work is gone in one day with a backhoe to the dump! Maybe an old pine or something is left to hold down the fort. It's sort of like a person who didn't do his or her housework for fifteen years, then just guts the house and rebuilds the inside. Well, that's one way to do it.

Frequently, some truly thoughtful and beautiful landscapes that have looked good through years of neglect get replaced with amazingly dull "low maintenance" landscapes. These are called "juniper-and-bark" places. They are just a cut above a parking lot itself, esthetically speaking. If you are thinking about tearing out your landscape and replacing it with all new plants, don't. First go to a nursery and start pricing new shrubs, noting the lack of anything of a full grown size. They're all babies! (Could it be that that's why it's called the "nursery"?) If you replace your landscape with new plants it will cost a fortune, and if you find some full grown plants they will be astronomically priced and twice as likely to die the first year. When you get your new babies home you will be tempted to plant them too close together so that the yard looks okay now. That is sort of like building a playhouse the right size for your two-year-old and expecting him to live in it forever. Plants must grow and get bigger (most of them, anyway). You cannot successfully stop their doing it. Some people ask for "fast-growing" plants in an effort to get a good landscape sooner. The bad news is that fast-growers don't stop once they get to where you want them. So now you've paid a fortune to take out a landscape that had probably maxed-out in size, and you've replaced it with a new, expensive one that is designed to be a mess in half the time.

So what is the alternative?

Sort Out, Renovate, Rehabilitate, and Exterminate!

You can think of the renovation process as the "this old house" of landscapes. In renovating a house you learn how to replace the knob-and-tube electrical wiring and what to do to refurbish the leaded glass windows and hardwood floors. In our yard renovation, we kill the laurel, keep the dogwood, move the rhody, and renovate the forsythia.

See this chapter in action.

SUMMARY
Common errors are:
- Cut it all back and make it smaller.
- Remove it all and plant a new yard. The first doesn't work and the second is too expensive or takes too long to look good.
- Pruning is one tool to use in renovating the overgrown yard.
- There are no maintenance-free yards. Your goal should be to eliminate unnecessary work while maximizing natural beauty.

Forward to Sorting Out

Back to How to Prune a Tree Limb