PlantAmnesty Back to
Book Index

The Complete Guide to Landscape Design, Renovation, and Maintenance
by Cass Turnbull

ADDING THE LOWER STORY
When people plant their yards they tend to do it like putting in furniture--up against the wall, in rows along the edges. And, as you know, too close together because, unlike your footstool, a shrub doubles or triples its volume. After the homeowner puts in the shrub, he digs a bed around it to fit, and that's it. Even though the shrub gets bigger, the bed stays the same size. Sometimes, grass being the way it is, the bed even gets smaller. This creates the optical illusion that your shrub is too big, when actually the shrub bed is too small. Cutting a shrub back to fit the bed is sort of like cutting your house plant back to fit the pot. In your yard it might be time to repot!

When pruning alone doesn't work.
When pruning along doesn't work, consider enlarging the shrub beds and rearranging the shrubs. This is often the longer-lasting and better solution.

At the yard of one of my favorite clients, a grouping of evergreen azaleas finally became so big that they were crowding each other and those next to the edge of the lawn were being held back by the edger's going by, chop, chop, chop! It looked like water building up behind a dam. The beds simply needed to be made bigger and the azaleas rearranged so that they looked comfortable again. The amount of work was minimal compared to hacking back the azaleas every year. People don't realize how very easy it is to dig up plants and move them around. They also are wary of the idea of removing lawn. Yet, the amount of lawn removed is often negligible. Most people can't even tell when lawn has been reduced by about a foot or three.

Sacred Grass: Don't Let It Ruin Your Yard
Some people are afraid that more shrub bed space will mean more weeding. This is not the case and the effect of the larger beds on the overall beauty of a yard is quite significant. They also dread digging up turf. Do it anyway! And bury it in a compost hole in the corner of your yard. Or, turn it over, cover it with water and black plastic. Next year it will be great compost!

You should also surround your trees with dirt and mulch, not lawn. This area is called a "tree well." The absence of turf will make the trees grow faster. If you mulch, you won't need to weed much. Besides, tree wells are great places for bulbs, ground covers and perennials, ferns and whatnot. Tree wells not only increase the growth rate of your tree but they greatly improve its chances of survival during drought. And you won't be tempted to girdle or injure your tree with the weedeater, causing troublesome suckers. Large tree wells make your tree look comfortable, and help to keep it from appearing too big.

So, make your beds bigger--much bigger, as big as you dare, certainly out beyond the dripline of your trees and shrub canopy. And move some plants around until it all looks good. Good gardeners are always digging things up and moving them around. Small plants are easy to move, but even big trees are movable. Americans used to move trees bigger than we do now, with horses and wagons. The limiting factor is power lines. No tree on its side can be taller than those wires. We're talking BIG. Get over the idea that anything in your yard is or should be of a permanent size or location. Gardens are kinetic art, just very slow moving. Your job is to manage them in motion.

Some plants are easy to transplant and some aren't. Tree-likes are easiest and look good right away. Cane growers, especially ones with mat-like roots, are harder. It's difficult to get a real root ball, and things tend to fall apart. Mexican orange, for example, can just be cut back drastically and maintained at a lower level rather than being moved. Rhododendrons are easiest because their rootballs are like pancakes. I've moved rhodies up to six feet with help from friends. It's a fun project.

How To Move A Rhododendron
First, make sure your plant is healthy. Next, dig a trench around the outside as if you were planning to make a root ball bigger than you could carry. When you are down past where the roots go, flip your shovel over and start chipping the roots and dirt back with the back side of your shovel and digging dirt out from under the roots using the back of the shovel. This protects the roots and makes a clean, tight root ball. Towards the end, you flip the shovel back right side up and stomp on it under the root ball in an attempt to slice the final roots. Keep an already-dull pair of root loppers to cut any big anchoring roots as you run into them. These are not the roots you need to handle with care. They just hold the plant down and store energy. It's all the tiny, tiny rootlets which absorb nutrients and water that need special treatment. This means you 1) do not break up the root ball, 2) do preserve as many rootlets as possible, 3) do keep them in dirt, 4) do keep them moist/wet, and 5) do not let them dry out in the open air. Each minute counts.

If the plant is big, have your buddy tilt it by pulling or pushing it over while you dig and slice. NEVER, NEVER yank the shrub out or pry up on it with your shovel. Just keep working on it, digging and slicing, until you feel it get loose. You will know when that is. Now, rock the plant and slide a big tarp under it, then rock it the other way. Have your buddy pull the edge of the tarp on through and under the plant. Use the tarp to tug it out of its hole. Sometimes you can give it a gentler ride out of the hole using a board as a runway. If your shrub is big, you and your friends can slide it out, pull it on the tarp, and drag your plant over to its new home. If your shrub is truly huge, you can rig something up with a chain and truck, tying the rope to the tarp used sort of like a diaper around the root ball. Do NOT tie it to the trunk. Trees and shrubs with great gashed trunks will usually die from the injury--later--probably next spring or in the late summer. If your shrub is three or four feet tall or under, you won't need to go through this trouble. You can just do it by yourself. Use your shovel handle to measure how broad and deep a hole to dig. Dig it, slide the shrub into the hole, and bury it. Then, WATER, WATER, WATER! Today, tomorrow, and next week.

It is always best to transplant broadleaf evergreens when it is cool or warm and wet, not hot and dry or cold and frozen. That means spring or fall. Summer is stressful for plants even if you water them. They need a lot more water than in milder temperatures. Very cold weather also dries them. It is possible to transplant things off-season, but it's considerably more stressful for them. Deciduous plants and needled evergreens transplant well in early winter when they are dormant, but do not wait until the weather is below freezing.

Land of Giants (See how to deal with them here.)
Sometimes you have a yard where all the plants are giants, but they're not crowding each other. They're just all sort of huge. Instead of cutting them back or moving them or killing them, you may just need to complement or contrast them with some smaller shrubs or plant understory.

If you have a row of giants you may need to remove one to break up the giant wall effect, as well as generally thinning to give them definition.

A pleasing yard has a top, a middle, and a lower story, you will recall. That is, trees, shrubs, and small things (ferns, flowers, ground covers). Having a yard full of all mature shrubs is imposing; having one with nothing but small things looks vulnerable. A wildflower meadow alone will not protect you from the big bad street. A nice garden is balanced with all three stories. Sometimes, for a woodland effect, skip the middle story and put in wonderful woodland plants inside and under your giants, like ferns, bleeding heart, trillium, hellebores, and hardy cyclamen. Under your deciduous flowering shrubs put spring bulbs that bloom at the same time as the shrubs, such as daffodils with your forsythia. Add a ring of lower plants around your giant mounds, maybe something with a contrasting color or texture, or, conversely, add something tall and skinny. Add contrast to your mature shrubs and your garden will seem parklike and tame again.

Yes, I'm afraid this chapter is a plot to get you to buy more plants. Really, really nice gardens have four or five stories, starting with a few enormous trees and working down. Under every plant is a smaller treasure or bulb, and vines clamber up walls and through trees. You can find rare ferns and flowers growing from chinks in walls, and you can even find tiny flowers throughout the lawn. If you are a lawn worshiper, as opposed to a flower worshiper, as is my next-door neighbor, you may wish to forego the lawn flowers. I thought she would have a heart attack when I proudly pointed to the English lawn daisy I had just planted. She works so hard to eliminate them from her yard.

SUMMARY
Alternatives to cutting back shrubs are:
(1) Make beds bigger
(2) Rearrange plants
(3) Eliminate some plants
(4) Make beds bigger and add more lower shrubs
(5) Or, thin out mature shrubs and add woodland understory and other smaller plants down in and amongst them.

Forward to Speaking and Understanding Gardenese

Back to Sorting Out